Cookie Sewell's Armory
Armor Kit Reviews from 2000

November 4, 2000

Book Review: Russian Motor Books Vehicles in Russia - Silver Collection,

"Armeyskiye Avtomobili" (Military Trucks).

Armeyskiye Avtomobili Number 3, ZiS/ZiL-150/164; 20 pp, Price $7.95.

Armeyskiye Avtomobili Number 4, YaAZ/KrAZ-214/255/260, 16 pp., Price $7.95.

Armeyskiye Avtomobili Number 5, GAZ-51/63, 16 pp., Price $7.95.

Armeyskiye Avtomobili Number 6, ZiS/ZiL-151/157, 16 pp., Price $7.95.

Armeyskiye Avtomobili Number 8, Ural-375/4320, 20 pp., Price $7.95.

Advantages: Probably the only source available on these vehicles for the foreseeable future.

Disadvantages: Somewhat esoteric for many modelers; more "nuts and bolts" than "Nuts and Bolts".

Rating: Highly Recommend (Hey, it's the ONLY game in town here!).

Recommendation: For Soviet/Russian soft skin fans.

For those of you familiar with the monographs published by Allied Command Productions of Canada, they hit on a winning formula to assist modelers with specific subject items: extract and clean up information from the "Dash-10" and shop manuals for a specific subject, clean up photos and diagrams, and package it in a new, easy-to-use guide for correcting or super detailing a model. Prices vary according to the depth and amount of information placed in their guides. If you've ever checked out the prices of manuals -- from $20 to $250 each, based on rarity and size -- then you can see where this is a great idea.

Now along comes a new enthusiast publisher from Russia, Russian Motor Books. The listing on the inside and outside of each of these slickly printed little pamphlets shows that they are oriented more on civilian automobiles, and have a 20-part series, Vehicles of the World, for sale and subtitled "Avtomobil'niye Voyni" (Car Wars) which covers the development of cars in the US, Europe and Asia since 1950. They also offer two other series -- Tanks in Russia, with at least one volume on the shop manual for the IS-3 heavy tank with plans and sketches, and Vehicles in Russia, which are the subject of this review.

Each booklet is similar to the format used by Allied Command Productions, but the Russians do include a short history of the vehicle in English as well as basic captions of photos for non-Russian speakers. They provide many diagrams of what the US reader would call "lube orders" and "Dash-25 Parts" manuals. A few 1/72 and 1/35 plans are also included for the modeler.

The ZiL-164 is a 4 x 2 3 metric ton truck that, as the ZiS-150, replaced the ZiS-5 series after the end of WWII. It is styled after Lend-Lease trucks and the resemblance to Studebaker and GMC trucks is obvious. There are no major commercial kits of this vehicle.

The KrAZ-214 is a heavy 12 metric tom rated 6 x 6 cargo truck used for artillery prime movers as well as specialty engineer vehicles such as the TMM-1 bridge launcher. It is still in service in the final KrAZ-260 version. There are no major commercial kits of this vehicle.

The GAZ-51/63 was a lightweight 4 x 4 2 metric ton rated cargo vehicle that came out after WWII and was designed with consideration of the Chevrolet 1 ½ ton series trucks from Lend Lease. It was widely exported and used, beginning in Korea during that war. There are no major commercial kits of this vehicle.

The ZiS/ZiL-151/157 3 ton 6 x 6 cargo vehicles were directly copied from Lead-Lease cargo trucks after the end of WWII, entering service in 1947. The main difference is that the 151 used 10 8.25 x 20.00 wheels, whereas the 157 used only 6 12.00 x 18.00 high mobility wheels and tires with adjustable tire pressure. The Italeri BM-13-16 "Katyusha" kit and its Zvezda ZiL-151 can be detailed nicely with this book, as can the SKIF kits of the BTR-152 which used an unmodified ZiL-157V or V1 chassis, as well as their smaller 1/72 ICM cousins.

The Ural-375, 375D, and 4320 are all evolved versions of the same 1960 5 metric ton 6 x 6 cargo truck design. This vehicle is still in use and for sale today, both as a cargo truck and a number of special purpose vans or the legendary BM-21 "Grad" multiple rocket launcher. This book is in invaluable for building and detailing the Omega-K/ICM kits of the Ural-4320 and the BM-21 "Grad", but unfortunately does not provide for the unique forward-mounted muffler and exhaust with guard found on all BM-21 vehicles.

While these are not what one could call "high-demand" items, they are very, very useful in providing items which are necessary to build the latter two families of models, and given the Russian and Eastern European penchant for releasing kits of interest to their fans, will eventually be nice to have for those trucks as well. They do clear up a lot, for example, the fact that the Ural-4320 DOES have twin steering linkages, the right side one employing a steering booster for use in rough terrain or muddy conditions. (I have to admit I was more than a bit skeptical of the Omega-K kit when I first saw that feature.) It also shows that the missing exhaust system on the BTR-152V should come out on the right side just above the center of the forward rear tire.

Overall, this is a nice but niche-oriented series of publications. A small number are currently available from Eastern Front Hobbies, PO Box 873, Madison, AL 35758; (256) 971-1224 at the prices listed above plus $2 for postage.

Cookie Sewell
AMPS


October 20, 2000

Kit Review: Dragon Models Limited 1/35 ‘39-‘45 Series Kit No. 6141; Sd.Kfz. 250/5 Neu le Beob.Pz.Wg.; 396 parts (396 in light grey styrene, 1 section nylon screening); retail price $28.

Advantages: first model of this particular version; follows DML modular sprue layout.

Disadvantages: The "Busy" assembly of the running gear is not everyone's cup of tea.

Rating: Highly Recommended.

Recommendation: for all German armor fans and modelers looking for a centerpiece for a vignette or diorama.

F I R S T L O O K

DML continues to produce variations on their 250 halftrack series, and the "slash 5" is the newest member of the family. For those not familiar with German terms, few that there may be, the abbreviation listed in the instructions breaks out to "liechter Beobachtungspanzerwagen" or "light armored observation vehicle". These vehicles were used as forward observation posts at division, regiment and battalion levels in combined arms units.

They came in two versions. The Sd.Kfz. 250/5.I, which was equipped with an Fu 4, an Fu 8, and the standard Funk f (28-33 MHz) tactical radio sets, and which was designed for use in cooperation with other arms. The Fu 4 (approximately 3000-7500 kHz) was its artillery liaison set, and the 30-watt Fu 8 (1130-3000 kHz) was the division to battalion HF radio set. This vehicle had a frame antenna, like the well-known "Greif" (an Sd.Kfz. 250/3 alt).

The second version, the Sd.Kfz. 250/5.II, was equipped with an Fu 12 set and the Funk f inter-vehicular radio set. The Fu 12 was an 80-watt HF (1200-3000 kHz) set that used a single rod type antenna with a "crow's foot" set of radiators at the top. This is the version provided in the DML kit. The kit follows the past DML breakout, with sprues A, B, C, E and F from earlier kits, a G sprue with the "crow's foot" antenna in four parts, a supplemental a sprue with the Fu 12 and necessary interior bits, an f sprue with the scissors binoculars of this variant, and W, Y and Z sprues with engine parts and a driver figure. Two-piece separate link tracks are part of this set, and while very nice, these have not been well received by some modelers as they are "fiddly bits" to be sure.

Unfortunately the only reference I have for the 5.II is for an "alt" model, and there are some stowage differences between the "alt" and the "neu" versions. However, all of the key parts are present, especially the radio sets and the scissors binocular with mount and case, so it does appear relatively accurate. Decals are included for two different vehicles: one unidentified Wehrmacht unit on the eastern front in a tricolor scheme, and one from the "Wiking" SS division in an unidentified location in Panzerbraun. Note that the box art shows SS personnel in the Wehrmacht scheme, which is not right according to the directions.

Overall, a nice effort and one that should become popular with German vehicle modelers.

Cookie Sewell
AMPS


October 20, 2000

Kit Review: Archer Fine Transfers Allied Uniform Sheets:

Set FG35017, U.S. WWII Rank Patches; includes all ranks (288 items); price $7.95.

Set FG35018, U.S. Uniform Patches; U.S. Rangers, 1st and 29th Infantry Division patches (approximately 120 items); price $15.95.

Set FG35019, U.S. Armor Division uniform patches; All WWII Divisions (100 items); price $13.95.

Set FG 35020, British rank insignia patches; all enlisted ranks including Warrant Officers (198 items); price $7.95.

Set FG 35021, British 3rd Division uniform patches (approximately 210 items); price $10.95.

Advantages: Professional quality finishing touches for infantry and tank crew figures; incredible detail needs a magnifying glass to see.

Disadvantages: Transfers are of the dry/rubdown variety, not everyone's cup of tea.

Rating: Highly Recommended.

Recommendation: for all US and British modelers, especially with armor or D-Day subjects in mind.

Woody Vondracek always continues to amaze me with his ability to produce gorgeous sheets of transfers, and the five newest ones are no different than the past surprises. Each one of these sheets is dead on register, superbly printed, and incredible to believe. If you have a good magnifying glass, every item of the original patch is visible and perfectly readable.

Sheet 35017 is WWII US Army rank from PFC (E-6) to MSG (E-1) with T-5, T-4, and T-3 grades as well. Sufficient chevron sets are included for up to 144 figures, so this is a good investment.

Sheet 35018 is a D-Day sheet, with shoulder patches for the 1st and 29th Infantry Divisions at Omaha Beach, and the other markings are leadership stripes and Ranger lozenges. Also included are about 40 gas mask carrier bag markings in yellow.

Sheet 35019 is for US Armor forces. There are 10 each for the 1st, 2nd, 3rd, 4th, 5th, and 6th Armored Divisions, and 4 each for the 7th, 8th, 9th, 10th, 11th, 12th, 13th, 14th, 16th and 20th.  The first 14 divisions are supplied with their postwar slogan tabs in place, so ensure that you trim these off for use on WWII figures. This provides enough patches to do at least one crew for the 7th to 20th and two crews from the 1st to 6th divisions.

Sheet 35020 covers British rank insignia, from Lance Corporal through Warrant Officer 1. Care will be needed with the warrant and specialist ranks, so once again I recommend a magnifying glass.

Sheet 32021 covers just the British 3rd Infantry Division. Included are shoulder flashes for nine subordinate units of the division, including Royal Warwickshire, Royal Norfolk, Royal Ulster Rifles, and others. All are readable with the now-standard recommendation of a glass, and very neatly done.

I don't know about you, but as I get older any sort of advantage in getting a great finish is high on my list of items to seriously consider investing in, and these sets are sure on that list. While prices may seem high, anyone who attended Woody's seminar at AMPS 2000 knows that the cost is proportional to the amount of work involved, meaning the number of colors used on a specific sheet of transfers. The stripes use two, the British 3rd set five, the US armored markings five, and the D-Day set eight. Also, these sets should last all but someone doing a 1:1 representative model of Omaha Beach several projects at the very least, and probably years in other cases.

I have used other sets, and I do have to say honestly that Woody makes the best, period.

Cookie Sewell
AMPS


October 8, 2000

Kit Review: Armoured Brigade Models 1/35 Scale Resin Upgrade Kits:

Kit No. ABM014, M3 Lee Basic Upgrade Kit; 25 parts in light tank resin; price US $21.

Kit No. ABM015, M3 Grant Basic Upgrade Kit; 17 parts in light tan resin; price US $23.

Kit No. ABM018, Late Production Sherman Suspension Set; 84 parts in light tan resin; price US $20.

Advantages: Clean, neat, accurate and easy to assemble parts to upgrade older Sherman and Lee/Grant kits.

Disadvantages: Lee/Grant parts come without directions (see text).

Rating: Highly Recommended.

Recommendation: for all fans of US M3 and M4 series tanks.

When we first started doing the "Dog Pound" series of articles in the BORESIGHT, the idea was to describe older kits and what could be done to make them more acceptable from today's standards of modeling. The very first article centered on the 25-year-old Tamiya M3 Grant tank, which is far from accurate by today's standards. I pointed out how to fix all of the kit's major problems except for its out-of-scale and thoroughly awful turret.

Armoured Brigade Models, one of the best companies going in the after-market resin business, has recently release two new kits with just this sort of problem in mind. One kit fixes the basic problems in the M3 Grant, and the other fixes up the equally bad M3 Lee.

The M3 Grant kit provides only the basic parts needed for correcting and upgrading the kit. These include a lovely new turret with gun, elevating drum, race, and hatch and two flaps for the hatch. It also includes the correct early Grant stowage bins, new view ports all around, and the driver's viewer which goes in front of the turret on the hull roof (and which all of the British Grant fans immediately belabored me for missing in the original "Dog Pound" article!) Two "coffee can" exhaust pipes and mufflers are included for those who wish to make a very early model Grant.

The M3 Lee kit provides a new turret with drum and compensator, cupola with scale two-section hatch, elevating drum, two machine gun barrels, new view ports, new low stowage bins, and a six-piece new rear end (the original kit is an M3A5 riveted tank with diesel engine, not an M3) including the original early "coffee can" exhaust pipes. It also includes a counterweight for those who wish to model a tank with the early M2 cannon (the kit provides for the later one with internal counterbalance, but that is more suitable for the longer M3 gun.)

Neither set unfortunately provides any directions. This is not so bad, as most of the parts are either a direct swap for the original kit parts or very obvious as to where and how they fit. Any modeler who wants to make an accurate M3 Grant or Lee needs to be aware that the kit's road wheels are wrong (six spoke cast versus the accurate five spoke cast wheels) and the tracks are likewise totally wrong (the connecters are attached to the center of the links rather than the ends) and all these parts need to be replaced as well.

One thing to watch for is trimming the casting nubs off from the turret race. ABM did an excellent job of casting the turrets hollow in one piece, but the results are the injection points for the resin around the lower rim of the turret. These will have to be gently cleaned out before the race is cemented in place with ACC cement. You will then have to remove most of the Tamiya turret base (the one with the keyhole in it for the turret race which comes in the kit) to accept the new turret base. Another alternative is to use the kit base as a pattern to make a blank plate, fit it to the turret, and use a suitable circle of plastic and section of strip to create a new keyhole lock (if you aren't doing an interior, that may be the best way to go!)

For those building the later M4 series, ABM now also is releasing their excellent replacement bogie sets. They cover early, mid-production and late, as well as M3 bogies (which solve the wheel problem listed above). The differences cover the return rollers, skid plates and risers. This kit comes with the late-model "upswept" return roller mounts with optional riser blocks and final model skid plates. Very complete photographic directions show step-by-step assembly.

Overall, these are great kits and are provided at very reasonable prices. Kits are now available from some select dealers, or from either Armour Brigade Models, PO Box 35163, Westgate PO, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada K1Z 1A2, or from Chesapeake Model Designs, PO Box 393, Monkton, Maryland 21111.

Cookie Sewell
AMPS


October 8, 2000

Kit Review: Trumpeter (Wasan Plastic Model Company) 1/35 Scale Kit MM-021/00321; Type 69-II in Iraqi Army Service; 316 parts (288 in olive drab plastic, 18 poly caps, 4 clear plastic, 2 vinyl tracks, 1 nylon screen, 1 nylon string, 1steel screw, and 1 pre-installed and wired electric drive train, plus a small tube of cement); price varies from $20-35 depending on source.

Advantages: first kit of this tank in production anywhere; more accurate in some respects than ESCI T-55 kits.

Disadvantages: odd type of plastic (NOT styrene) will make correcting errors/swapping parts difficult.

Rating: Recommended.

Recommendation: For those needing a "background" tank in an Iraqi War diorama, or anyone who wants a "runner" for the fun of it.

Thus far I have to admit that I have been disappointed with the Trumpeter kits from China, in that they are either not very accurate -- having a lot of compromises made in their design to permit motorization, or are nearly impossible to assemble with anything other than the tube cement included in the kits.   The plastic is not "world standard" styrene but some variation of ABS or similar high-impact plastic, and it makes working with the material a problem.

Having completed one of their kits (the Type 80, actually a Type 88 B or C) with much misery, I was not thinking of doing any more with them until Vern Goodrich purchased one of the Type 69-II tank kits at AMPS 2000. I recently picked this kit up to see if it was as good as the one Vern had looked in the box, and so far it is better than expected.

The Type 69 was the follow-on to the Chinese Type 59 copy of the Soviet T-54 tank. It is roughly the Chinese equivalent of a T-55 with a number of improvements made to it internally, and a choice of armaments. The Type 69-I was a Chinese-only version with a 100mm smoothbore gun, which apparently doomed it to domestic consumption only. The Type 69-III was an upgraded version, mounting a Chinese version of the British L7A1 105mm rifled gun. The Type 69-II used the Chinese version of the Soviet D-10T2S 100mm gun, and as it fired the exact same ammunition as the T-54 and T-55, was a natural export tank. It came in three versions: BW121A line tank, BW121B battalion commander's tank, and BW121C company commander's tank. The latter two had extra radios, an antenna case on the turret roof, and stowage for cables and field telephone equipment on their rear plates.

The kit provides the parts only for the A model line tank, but some study of photos of destroyed or captured tanks should yield enough info to make the B or C models. The antenna case is provided (part B32) along with mounting hole blanks in the turret roof.

Some parts are rather odd. The wheels are better done than the ESCI T-55 but then have segmented rims that are incorrect. The turret shape is surprisingly accurate with the gun offset and bulge for the gunner present, and the 100mm gun is far better than the under scale and lame attempt at the L7A1 provided in the Type 80 kit (which shares its main parts sprue with this one).

The electric drive is pre-installed and wired up in the hull, and no axle is included to replace it with a non-driven version. This can be replaced and the drive trashed to use its axle if desired. The motor did work when tested, spinning the axle at high RPM with a lot of torque, so it does appear that the little beast is "Designed to be Driven" as the commercials used to say. At least this kit uses poly caps rather than screws to attach the wheels, so it is not as difficult to "defrock" the motor drive nor turn it into a scale model. There are only two holes in the hull to fill (motor screw mount and front screw attachment hole) so it's much easier than older Tamiya kits to deal with.

Some detail parts leave much to be desired. The RPG guards, cheerily referred to in Chinese sales literature as "Boom Shields" have the correct profile of being flat and not rounded as portrayed by some after-market manufacturers. But they are too thick and not deep enough; the actual blades in the shields are about 3/16" thick and 2½ - 3" wide, and these are about .030" x 030" square or 1" square tube in scale. Careful filing and attaching segments of Evergreen strip to the backs should improve their appearance. The kit's suggested holes also seem off from the box photos; all of the bases of the "boom shield" baskets should be in line and parallel to the hull roof, which the ones on the example clearly do not do. Figure on fiddling with the rear section to get a level fit.

The kit's directions are not much help, but you do have a lot of options on how to fit this model out. Parts A16 and A17 are the early model headlight guards, which only lack a strip of non-skid steel on the top to complete them (open up the fender holes at the front edge of the hull top for using them); they're an alternative to the kit's late model parts A5. The kit also has the armored covers for the searchlights (parts A77, A78, and A29) as well as the laser range finder (parts A9 and A12).

A rather blatantly copied set of decals (swiped from the "Desert Storm" vintage DML kits) are provided with both Standard and Arabic numbers. (Iraqis only used Arabic).

Overall this kit does have possibilities, but its choice of an off-register plastic makes assembly much more difficult and clean, neat modeling a real challenge. (PS it also does not take well to ACC glues, so your choices get even more limited as time goes on!)

Cookie Sewell
AMPS


September 27, 2000

Kit Review: Heiser's Models, Inc. HO 1/87 Scale Kits:

Kit No. 2338, M4 Sherman (Mid-Production Tank with 75mm Gun Turret); 79 parts in light olive styrene; price $7.95.

Kit No. 2340, M4A3 Sherman (Early Production Tank with 75mm Gun Turret); 79 parts in light olive styrene; price $7.95.

Advantages: Best game in town in this scale; modeler gets to call the options; fine scale tools and fittings.

Disadvantages: Puts the modeler back in modeling in some cases; some glitches (see comments below).

Rating: Highly Recommended.

Recommendation: for all small-scale Shermaholics and war gamers.

For years, the only game in town for HO scale armor modeler and those modelers or war gamers who wanted "fleets" of tanks pretty much were consigned here ROCO from Salzburg, Austria. Their first kits were 1/100 scale, but later models grew into full HO scale and made things much easier, plus much nicer.

Also, ROCO's founder's boyhood friend opened Trident, a white-metal HO military kit manufacturer, which later began to produce plastic injected models as well. A few other manufacturers got into the same venue, most prominently Preiser of Germany.

A few attempts were made to produce HO kits or fully assembled models by other companies, but most either failed or were bought out by ROCO. Such was the case with the Petner Panzers T-72M kit, and the Russian Premo line is now totally marketed by ROCO. Now a new player has stepped up, Heiser's Models, Inc. of California.

The packet states that Heiser's is going to concentrate on armored vehicles of the 1930s to 1950s, which is an overlooked area in this scale. Most of the ROCO kits start in the 1943-44 time frame, and only the Premo kits of the early Soviet tanks cover the earlier era.

These two kits are essentially identical except for the upper hull of the Sherman tank being modeled. The M4 has the proper solid deck and notched rear panel, and the M4A3 the grilles and "tail" to the rear panel. However, both kits apparently have the later shallow angle rear to the turret without loader's hatch. Also the rear plate is the same for both kits, one that appears to have either an early set of M4 mufflers or round air cleaners. This is partially wrong for the M4 mid-production and totally wrong for the A3. The hull comes in six parts, a belly pan with sponsons (are you listening, Tamiya???!), hull, transmission cover, rear plate, and two ROCO-type unitary track runs. The idlers are the "straight" top type with lift blocks. Track is T51 smooth rubber type, but that is basically a fact of molding single-piece track runs without an astronomically complex mold. Heiser's has their logo on the outside of the bottom of the hull, but it is easy to clean up. The kit was apparently molded in Taiwan by a company called HSI for Heiser's.

The modeler has a choice of either the M34 or M34A1 gun mount and shield, as well as a ton of minor details. Included with the latter is a choice of either M2 .50 caliber or M1917A4 .30 caliber machine guns, "split" hatch or vision cupola, tool sets and optional layouts, one German and one US jerry cans, and lift rings, lights, etc. None of the light guards are modeled, but then again, there are no "lumps" to shave off.

While some modelers may grouse at the errors, Heiser's provides a very detailed double-sided instruction sheet and a set of plans of the version of the model into which the kit builds. They have a very nice explanation of why the kits are set up the way they are. For war gamers, the tank can be slapped together in a few minutes to serve its purpose and fragile items left off the model to make it more "playable". For modelers, the details are provided but the modeler will have to come up with the missing "bits" on his own. Case in point is the loader's hatch, which Heiser's recommends sanding very thin before installing. Heiser's also provides resin or white metal parts with their other kits, noting a resin three-piece transmission cover with the early M4A1 kit and white metal tracks with early style bogies. They also have a resin hull for the M4A2.

Overall, these are nice little kits, and considerably better than the 35-year-old ROCO M4 model. I am not sure of where to find Heiser's on a regular basis. I picked these two up in a model railroad shop sale in

Charlottesville, VA. Their address is: Heiser's Models, Inc., PO Box 6187, Lakewood, CA 90714-6187, phone/fax (562) 860-1362. A catalogue can be had for a SASE (55 cents postage in the US). Their e-mail address is: heisermodels@earthlink.net.

Cookie Sewell
AMPS


September 17, 2000

Kit Review: Eastern Express 1/35 Scale Kit No. 35132; GAZ-66 Army Truck with ZU-23-3 Antiaircraft Mounting; 246 parts (164 black styrene plastic, 69 in light grey styrene, 8 clear styrene plastic, 5 vinyl tires); price between $20-28.

Advantages: Good truck kit re-released by larger company insures wider availability; ZU-23-2 gun is a jewel in its own right.

Disadvantages: Some annoying mold sinks or incomplete plastic injection; instructions for the gun are incomplete; no markings for box top subject (see text).

Rating: Highly Recommended.

Recommendation: for all modern warriors, AA gun fans, and diorama artists.

F I R S T    L O O K

There is an ongoing movement in Russia and the former Soviet Union countries right now for their recently created model companies to consolidate. This has been true in Ukraine, where ICM is buying a number of smaller companies and now providing an "umbrella" releasing agency for them along with their own line of kits; note their new releases are now ex-Omega-K kits. The same is true of Eastern Express, a new company that has consolidated its own new kits of KV series heavy tanks with those of Scale Ltd. and now markets then under its label.

One of the new combined kits is this double kit, which combines the very nicely done GAZ-66 from Scale Ltd. which did not meet with great response when released due to the small size of the company and difficulty in finding in the US and some other markets (they seem to have been more common in the UK) and a new sprue with the very well known and popular ZU-23-2 towed AA gun mount.

The GAZ is the current light standard truck of the Russian Armed Forces, and while similar in size to the popular Unimog 1700 series and rated as a 2 metric ton vehicle, is used in much the same way as the US uses its 1 1/4 ton series trucks or the UK 110" wheelbase Land Rovers. It was developed in the mid 1960s to replace the older GAZ-63 series light cargo trucks, and combined its cab-over-engine design with a similar size chassis to create a very useful and reliable truck. While basically out of production now, it is still in widespread use in the former USSR states and many of the former Soviet client states.

The ZU-23-2 is still the most popular heavy weapon in the Russian inventory. It was developed in the 1950s as a harder-hitting ground forces support weapon based on their very powerful 23mm rounds for aviation cannon, and after a number of trials was accepted for service in 1960 as the 2A13 automatic antiaircraft cannon. This consisted of two 2A14 guns mounted in a Siamese mounting with the guns "handed" for easier feed and operation. Over the years the gun provided itself to be very good not only at tactical AA protection, but also in anti-vehicle and anti-personnel operations. They were extensively used in Afghanistan and Chechnya by the Russians as their high-angle fire and still potent ammunition made them great for sniper suppression and covering fire. Literally thousands of these guns are in use today in a total of over 50 countries.

Both kits are complete, but to the modeler's great frustration, Eastern Express "assumes" the modeler only wants to build the kit as per the box top painting! This is for a gun minus its wheels and set in the firing position. My best guess based on photos of the actual gun are: parts 49 and 54, wheels; parts 31, wheel retainers; parts 29 and 30, rotating axle mounts; 27-28 and 53-54, axle bearing/swivel mounts; parts 9 and 10, fenders; parts 7-8 and 57-58, fender mounts; part 3, folding towing lunette. With a photo of the actual gun, you can work out where these bits go; sadly Eastern Express did not do that for you from the beginning.

Happily, the only difference in the truck kit is stripping off the troop seats, which Eastern Express does show in their directions.

The truck has a nice engine, but it was spoiled on my example due to incomplete molding of some of the fine parts and a big sinkhole in the middle of the detailed part of the air filter. There are also the usual assortment of ejection pin marks and other items that are not done well by many eastern model companies, but overall the kit is nicely done. The cab tilts to show the engine, and problems like those found on the ICM Ural-4320 are avoided by having the windshield and frame molded in clear as one piece. Masking may prove tricky, but it does guarantee a good fit with the windows. The tires are hollow molded vinyl similar to those that come with the SKIF BTR-152V1 kit, and are hard to beat for a non-resin cast product.

The kit comes with a wide variety of marking and decals, including one UN set, one Russian Army, and two MVD Internal Troops , one of which is colorfully marked for Chechnya. Surprisingly, the box art takes no bones about its being an Iraqi vehicle with Iraqi gunners shooting at A-10s, but no markings are included for any non-Russian forces.

Overall, this is a little gem and should fill the bill for a lot of folks. Next year's AMPS Annual Convention theme is "Keeping the Peace", and this model fits nicely into that subject.

Cookie Sewell
AMPS


September 17, 2000

Kit Review: Fruilmodel 1/35 track sets:

No. ATL-59, Chenilette Lorraine (all versions); 230 links in white metal, two drive sprockets in white metal, and a section of fastening wire; price $27-32 (estimated).

No. ATL-60, Churchill Tank (all variants); 170 links in white metal and a section of fastening wire; prices $27-32 (estimated).

Advantages: First single-link white metal tracks for these vehicles.

Disadvantages: some models do not like the new stick and clip' wire assembly.

Rating: Highly Recommended.

Recommendation: for all modelers doing a Chenilette Lorraine/Lorraineschlepper or any Churchill.

Fruilmodel continues to roll along, and the latest news is that now each of their track sets comes in a sturdy cardboard box with a photo of the subject on the top. Prices have been kept low due to the switch of manufacture to Hungary, and thus the quality is good and the prices are reasonable.

The Lorraine set is going to be very tedious to some modelers, as the links are very, very small and the idea of fishing together over two hundred of them for two track runs will bother some modelers and those of us who tend to have either minor bouts of arthritis or cramping in our fingers. They are about the size of 1/76 scale Panther tracks (not the same, so don't try swapping them!) to give you a rough idea of size.

The Churchill set, on the other hand, will replace the older Tamiya one and finally provide a nice fluid set of tracks for that vehicle that "hang" correctly and look good. They are so nice they almost demand doing an early model to get the exposed top track run or stripping the fenders off the Mk. VII kit versions. They are "normal" size and should not be as much of a problem.

The best method I've found for these so far is to "kink" the wire just prior to insertion, and friction and tension will hold it in place once installed. All you need is a set of wire cutters, needle nose pliers, and a small drill to clear flash from the hinges to assemble. All in all, two nice efforts.

Cookie Sewell
AMPS


September 17, 2000

Kit Review: Revell AG 1/35 Scale Kit No. 03038; Tpz-1 "Fuchs" A6 ABC; 272 parts (251 in green styrene, 6 in olive drab styrene, 8 clear styrene, 6 solid black vinyl tires, 1 section steel wire); price $16-23 Advantages: First kit of the this vehicle in this scale; very nicely detailed and provides the feeling of the "heft" of the actual machine.

Disadvantages: Will take work to make into anything but the German A6 variant; odd choice of details for such a complex kit.

Rating: Recommended.

Recommendation: for modern armor fans.

F I R S T    L O O K

The German Fuchs (Fox) 6 x 6 APC has been around for a number of years, and the Bundeswehr has a number of options that it sports in service. These include the straight APC version and the "Hummel" and ELOKA electronic warfare platforms. But the best-known version outside of Germany is the ABC (Atomic-Biological-Chemical ) version, better known in the US as the M93 Fox series NBC reconnaissance vehicles.

Revell AG has now produced a kit of the current German variant, the A6, which is not the same as the other ones loaned out to its NATO partners during Desert Shield, and later purchased. The base kit is the original Fuchs ABC model and can, if desired, be painted up for the Coalition partners in the Desert. A small supplemental sprue of parts (160-163) is included in OD plastic, and this apparently upgrades the kit to the current A6 variant vice older models. Note that the US now has the XM93E1 that changed a number of sensors, and cut the crew required to operate the vehicle from four to three. It also added US pattern equipment such as smoke grenade launchers and an M60 machine gun, etc.

Ignoring the non-American centric nature of the kit (I can't blame them for that!) the model is a really nicely molded kit. It is also an "omnibus" kit with most of the main optional parts included (such as the fighting compartment hatch options which mount in the center of the roof). It has a number of operating features, such as rotating and steerable water drive propellers, and working steering on the front two axles. The tires are beefy with the correct Michelin tread pattern, but appear a bit square in profile. I am not sure how these react with the steering, as they appear too much for the rods and spindly pins used to connect the linkage.

Oddest of all is the fact that the model comes with separate front doors and an optional position armored cover, as it has no interior. Also odd are the fact that the rear doors are sealed, as is the commander's hatch, so you don't even have any options on where to place figures if desired. Likewise, all of the optional center hatches over the fighting compartment are sealed, which seems odd to go to the trouble of providing separate parts and then make them closed. I guess the answer is reflected in the very reasonable price of the kit.

Overall this is a well-done kit, but considering its lack of options, will either take a ton of work or wind up relegated to being a "background" model in dioramas.

Cookie Sewell
AMPS


July 31, 2000

Kit Review: SKIF 1:35 Scale Model Kit No. 209; BTR-152V1; 243 parts (223 in light olive styrene, 13 etched brass, 7 rubber tires); price around $25-28.

Advantages: First kit in styrene of this vehicle; includes basic interior and engine components; nicely done rubber tires.

Disadvantages: Some sinkholes and ejector pin marks; main vehicle body is in 18 parts; interior fittings for hull sides missing in several places.

Rating: Recommended.

Recommendation: For all third world and Cold War fans.

F I R S T L O O K

The Soviets were proud of the industrialization efforts that they had made prior to WWII, but when they began to see the mechanical quality of the products provided by Lend Lease from the USA and Britain, they were embarrassed to see how backward they really were. The most impressive of all of the items they received were trucks from the USA. The Jeep was in a class by itself, and the two 2 ½ ton medium trucks, the Studebaker US6 and GMC CCKW, were far in advance of the crude Soviet ZIL-5 and GAZ-AAA models, and proved to be just as rugged and reliable but with more comfort, safety, and practicability. As a result, at the end of WWII the Soviets combined the best features from these vehicles to produce the ZIL-151, which was a near clone of the GMC chassis and drive line.

The ZIL-151 chassis had the main upgrade from the small 7.00 x 20.00 tires to larger 9.00 x 20.00. Later, the truck was upgraded to produce the ZIL-157 model. The ZIL-157V1 introduced adjustable air pressure for off-road movement along with single 12.00 x 18.00 tires. This latter truck served the USSR and many of its allies for many, many years, and is still in service with some of them today.

But during the war, one thing which the Soviets did not find particularly impressive were either the US or German half-tracked APCs. Both of them tended to have problems with the German ones were mechanically finicky, and the US models tended to shed tracks. The Germans did have a ballistically better body shape and design than the vertical walled US models. Since the Soviets had used the White Scout Car with good results, and liked the driveline of the GMC, they eventually combined the three elements together, an APC like the White Scout Car with a ballistically improved body similar to the German designs, but using the GMC-based driveline of the ZIL-157 truck.

This fit into the Soviets' post-war development of motorized rifle units for accompanying tank assaults and providing better protection to their crews and dismount teams than the tanks did during the war. The first model, which was based on the ZIL-151, was accepted for service in 1950 as the BTR-152. The vehicle had a crew of two and room for 17 motorized riflemen in the rear compartment, as well as carried one 7.62mm SGM machine gun that could be fixed to one of four mounts in the rear compartment. However, as with most of the BTR-152 family, the vehicle had no overhead cover from shell fragments.

The BTR-152 was followed in 1951 by the BTR-152A model which provided a mounting for a twin 14.5mm ZPU-2 AA gun; later models in this line included the ZTPU-4 of 1955 with a quadruple 14.5mm mount, the improved BTR-152Ye model with the ZTPU-2 mount but using a BTR-152V1 chassis, and one mounting a ZU-23 twin 23mm mount. There was also a BTR-152U version with a high roof to provide for staff functions such as map boards inside the vehicle.

The BTR-152V series followed in 1955, and this version added the central tire regulation system from the ZIL-157V. It changed from the 9.00 x 20.00 dual tires over to the 12.00 x 18.00 singles of the 157 and also made some minor improvements elsewhere, such as an SGMB machine gun. It mounted a 5,000 kg winch and other essential items. The last main production model, the BTR-152V1 that began production in 1958, switched from the external tire pressure regulators of the V model to the internal ones of the ZIL-157V1. It also provided mountings for the TVN-2 driver's night vision device.

The last model of the BTR-152 to see production was the BTR-152K that added a roof; however, by that time (1959) the move was to change over to the BTR-60PK and PB and thus production of these vehicles was limited. The BTR-152 series was dropped from Russian army service in 1993, but they remain in service with many other third-world nations today.

This is the newest kit from SKIF, and it fills a blank in many modelers' wish lists. In layout and format, it seems much like the ICM kits of the Ural-4320 series vehicles. It abounds with very nice touches, such as hollow-molded vinyl tires with very tiny inscriptions on each one as to size and point of manufacture. The kit also includes a photo-etched fret that provides the light guards as two parts (frame and screen) and a blade for the two-man engineer saw carried by many Soviet-era vehicles. All of the doors are hinged for operation, which has been funky on many of the other SKIF kits, but the hinges seem close to scale so this may not be a bad item. There is an engine included as well as an interior for the dismount compartment.

Some parts, however, are not as well detailed as others. The interior of the two main hull parts (108D and 109D) are bereft of the fittings and ports for the firing ports which are molded on their exterior sides. Likewise, the driver's and commander's windshield covers have only sketchy details on the insides, and none of the "bits" needed to open or hold them open. Likewise, the armored radiator cover (102D) is shut with only a slight tilt to the louvers.

An SGMB machine gun is included and consists of nine parts, with the handle brackets being etched brass.

The model comes with only one painting option (Soviet Khaki #2, a near olive drab color) and national markings for the Soviet Army (with a Guards badge), the DDR, Czechoslovakia, and Poland. The instrument panel is a decal and requires that the panel be painted Soviet Khaki #2 first. However, these vehicles have been widely sold and used and other schemes can be found to finish it. Choices include: Afghanistan, Albania, Algeria., Angola, Bulgaria, Chad, China, Congo, Cuba, Cyprus, Egypt, Equatorial Guinea, Ethiopia, DDR, Guinea, Hungary, India, Indonesia, Iran, Iraq, Israel, DPRK, Laos, Mali, Mongolia, Mozambique, Poland, Rumania, Somalia, Sri Lanka, Sudan, Syria, Tanzania, Yemen, Yugoslavia, North Vietnam, and Zaire. Some of these third-world schemes can be fairly inventive, but seeking them out will be an interesting task.

Overall, this is a nice kit, and SKIF has now worked its way up to about the same level of complexity and accuracy as Heller kits. While some modelers decry this, recall that this is only their seventh armor kit.

Thanks to Eastern Front Hobbies for the review sample.

Cookie Sewell
AMPS


June 20, 2000

Product Review: Third Group Decal Sets

Set 35-017, 1/35 Scale Sherman Set #1 for M4A1 (Early, Mid, and Late); markings for three M4A1 Shermans with directions included; price $5.95.

Set 35-018, 1/35 Scale Sherman Set #2 for M4 Composite Hull; markings for three M4 Composite Hull Shermans with directions included; price $5.95.

Advantages: Sharp, clean waterslide decals (printed by Microscale).

Disadvantages: M4A1 set overlaps kit offerings in DML M4A1 kit.

Rating: Highly Recommended.

Recommendation: For Shermaholics, especially those who want to do Pacific War Army M4s.

I have not used any of the decals from Third Group as all of the subjects until now were German, but these are the first two sets from this Washington Company on "my" turf.

Both sets have artwork and research by Third Group and are printed for them by Microscale, arguably the largest US waterslide transfer decal manufacturer. Printing is very sharp and clear, and sufficient decals are included on each sheet to do all three of the subjects covered. This is in comparison with other sheets which provide three sets of serials but only one set of stars, so will be much more useful to the "hoarders" out there.

Set #1 covers M4A1s, but two of the subjects are the same found in the DML M4A1 Early kit ("Weenie One" and "Eternity"). However, what Third Group does provide in their directions is a clear description of the actual vehicle as taken from photo sources, and as a result provide info on tracks, bogies, road wheels, and specific variations for the vehicle for which they provide markings.

Set # 2 covers M4 with the composite hull, all in the Pacific theater and all Army vehicles. These include the "tumbling dice" from the 775th Tank Battalion, the 763rd Tank Battalion on Anguar, and the 44th Tank Battalion in the Philippines. All are pretty straightforward.

Overall, nicely done sets and the ones on Pacific Shermans are particularly welcome. In the US these are available from Squadron Mail Order (via their web site) or from Third Group, PO Box 98545, Tacoma, WA 98498-0545.

Cookie Sewell
AMPS


June 20, 2000

Kit Review: Italeri 1/35 Scale Kit No. 372; Paladin S.P. Howitzer; 267 parts (264 in light olive drab styrene,2 silver vinyl tracks, 1 section of nylon mesh); price $27.

Advantages: The "good" Italeri made this kit; nice detailing and corrections to some past errors.

Disadvantages: Stiff tracks will not lie flat; some minor quirks.

Rating: Highly Recommended.

Recommendation: For all "gonners" and modern US fans.

F I R S T    L O O K

Before entering into the body of the review on this kit, due to the confusion caused by the path that this system has followed to get into production, a bit of history is called for.

In the late 1950s, a decision was made that the "Pentomic" weapons systems were too heavy to be easily deployable. The US Army had changed over to STRAC -- the STRategic Army Corps, which was the quick deployment heavy force for handing overseas hot spots -- but many of the weapons in STRAC units like the 2nd Armored Division were too heavy to send by air, and too bulky for shipboard use. As a result, a new family of lightweight aluminum combat and combat support vehicles took shape. The lightweight M113 series of APCs replaced the heavy M75 and M59 steel vehicles, and the new 105mm M108 and 155mm M109 replaced the 105mm M52 and 155mm M44 series of SP artillery pieces. Neither one was much lighter than the weapon it replaced, the 24-ton M108 replacing the 27-ton M52 and the similar M109 the 30-ton M44, but both vehicles could be floated with add-on pontoons and swim with track power. Also, both were NBC protected which the other two were not; they were also designed from the start to use diesel engines, as the Army was in the process of converting over from gasoline engines.

The family of weapons ran this way:

M108 - (Italeri Kit No. 238) SP 105mm howitzer, first fielded in 1962. Dropped in 1963 as the 105mm was not felt worthwhile in a large vehicle such as this, and the switch was made to the 155mm M109.

M109 - (Italeri Kit No. 235) SP 155mm howitzer with a 28-caliber barrel (artillery measures guns by bore or diameter of the inside of the barrel, and caliber, which is the number of times the diameter of the bore that the gun tube is long). Entered production in 1962, and dropped in 1967. Maximum range with normal ammunition 16,400 meters.

M109A1 -- SP 155mm howitzer with a 39-caliber barrel and an increased maximum range of 18,100 meters with conventional ammunition. Essentially a rebarreled M109. Kits went out to the field in 1972.

M109A2 -- (Italeri Kit No. 239) SP 155mm howitzer with a 39-caliber barrel and many internal changes. Differentiated from the M109A1 by a 32-round bustle and an armored cover for the panoramic sight head on the front left side of the turret. Entered production in 1978.

M109A3 -- SP 155mm howitzer with a 39-caliber barrel. An M109A1 brought up to full M109A2 standards. Converted as M109A1s were returned for depot maintenance.

M109A4 -- an M109A2 or M109A3 retrofitted with newer NBC protection and mechanical upgrades.

M109A5 -- an M109A4 upgraded to fire rocket-assisted or base bleed projectiles to a range of 30,000 meters. At one time this and the A4 were expected to mount a 53-caliber barrel, but thus far the Army has not opted for longer barrels.

M109A6  (Italeri Kit No. 372) this weapon began life as the "AHIP" or Advanced Howitzer improvement Program in 1984. A number of variations (the M109A3E2 being one) were tested and sent back for further evaluation before the M109A6 was finalized in 1992. The M109A6 is a conversion kit applied to an M109A4 or M109A5 stage 155mm howitzer. Production of conversion kits began in 1993, and kit production was reported to be complete in 1998. A total of 630 weapons were upgraded. Upon its official acceptance, the M109A6 was named "Paladin" by the US Army. (Note: Italeri also makes Kit No. 246, which combines German and prototype AHIP parts in one kit, but will not build into a Paladin.)

The Paladin is the current "ultimate" version of the 38-year-old M109 design. It is a highly automated weapons system and is capable of firing 3 rounds in 13 seconds. It is designed for "shoot and scoot" tactics, where the crew does not dismount or prepare the piece for long fires, but can be prepared for firing while buttoned up in an NBC environment, fire its mission, and prepare to move out automatically. Spades and the main gun travel lock are all operated from the interior with no crew egress needed to place them. It also uses a new design turret with blow-off bustle and Kevlar lining to protect the crew from counter battery fire. There is an Enhanced Paladin prototype with a 52-caliber barrel, but at this time US Army priorities are placed on the Crusader advanced howitzer system.

All that being said, the Paladin kit was apparently designed and built by the "Good" Italeri, as in the one which takes more care and tries not to skimp on parts (like the details on the Oshkosh or M939 truck families). The kit replaces the "C" sprue from the A2 kit with a new one of 67 parts, plus an "E" sprue with 40 more. Combined they add all of the parts needed to change the lowly M109 hull over to the new Paladin gun system.

Some parts are improved in the transition. The sight head cover for the panoramic sight (parts 130 and 131) no longer have a solid screen in them; true, you now need to get a small section of clear styrene to replace it, but it no longer means either having to fill a nasty seam or cutting the blank sides out to replace it anyway. The swing away bins on the rear sides of the bustle can be placed in normal or shipping (folded back) configuration, and the automatic travel lock can be left to operate. (Note: the "clear" arrows mean do not cement, and the solid ones mean use glue; one would think after all these years Italeri would bother to explain this on their instructions!)

The tracks are now molded in silver, but are the same stiff brutes we have had for years. At least in the US Squadron and MMD are now carrying the Skybow T-136 replacement single link styrene tracks, so replacing them is no longer catch as catch can.

One glaring error in the directions is the indication that the piece modeled is "Germany 1994". It's not, as the markings are for 1-37 FA of the 2nd Infantry Division in Korea. This is a tri-color (NATO) scheme weapon, and the sand scheme is totally inappropriate for Korea. Italeri should have at least been kind enough to include a second set of markings!

Overall, this piece is a very impressive one, and a nicer effort from Italeri than some of their recent offerings. It will be nicely matched with the PzH 2000 from Revell Germany and the forthcoming 2S19 from SKIF in representing modern artillery pieces.

Cookie Sewell
AMPS


June 11, 2000

Kit Review: Revell (Revell Monogram) Authentic Kit No. 85-5621; C.S.S. Alabama; 653 parts (2 in black styrene, 20 in creme colored styrene, 41 in white styrene, 570 in dark grey styrene, 10 vacuformed off-white sails, 6

pre-formed ratlines/shrouds, 1 section coarse brass chain, 1 section fine brass chain, 1 spool black cotton thread, 1 spool tan cotton thread, paper flag sheet); retail price $65.

Advantages: Re-release of an old favorite; molds not too badly deteriorated (see text).

Disadvantages: Lots of ejector pin marks, only an approximation of the original ship.

Rating: Recommended.

Recommendation: for all fans of this old favorite who don't like paying Ebay prices for originals.

When I was 13, two of the things which were tops on my Christmas list were the two 1/96 scale Civil War ship kits released by Revell to celebrate the centennial of the US Civil War: the USS Kearsarge and its legendary opponent, the CSS Alabama. The first one was $9.98 and the second one $11.98 that made them out of the league of someone lucky enough to get $2 for mowing a lawn. But Santa was on a budget that year, and Christmas came and went without either ship gracing the spot under the tree.

Two months later, the family owned store where my father worked (as part of the family) had a fire (put out by the sprinkler system ) that ruined one section of the storage inside the building. My uncle called for family to pitch in, and so I spent five hours lugging out soggy shoes and bras from the back rooms on the 2nd and 3rd floors of the store. My uncle was very happy with the help and as a reward for pitching in my father brought home the CSS Alabama two days later. Needless to say, I had a very happy time putting the beast together and it was always one of my favorite models, and even graced my mother's dining room table for a short while.

I noted that Revell re-released the CSS Alabama about 11 years ago, but at that time I was getting ready to retire from the Army and had no room for one. By the time I got settled, all of the re-released kits were snapped up and thus nowhere to be found.

Prices for the Alabama, and the rarer Kearsarge, were astronomical by 1999. (There is an urban legend, with probably a great deal of truth behind it, that Revell trashed the molds of the USS Kearsarge to get the CSS Alabama. They share a lot of parts and the hulls are nearly identical. However, both kits were offered at the same time in 1961, so think it was more likely a pantographed mold rather than a re-working.) Prices of $125 to $250 for either the original or the re-release were becoming common. I had to seriously think about that, after seeing an original 1961 CSS Alabama for sale for L65 ($97) at Plastic Past-Times in Poole, Dorset, six weeks ago.

Returning home, lo and behold, Revell-Monogram re-released the kit for $65. Admittedly this is a 40% jump over the 1989 re-release at $46, and 540% of the original 1961 price, but compared to Ebay, I'll take it!

Many older kits have suffered badly over the years, due to running the molds long past their amortization period. I was surprised to open the box and discover that the Alabama has fared better than most, and much of the original detail is still sharp and impressive. The model is now in a slightly modified version of the original "Frameable" box art carton with a John Steel painting, but it no longer comes in "Five Colors" of styrene. (The original came in dark grey, grey, dark brown, white, and a greenish tan for the decks.) All of the original parts are still included, along with the 20 figures that came with both the Alabama and Kearsarge kits and the vacuformed sails and pre-formed ratlines or shrouds.

There are some serious ejection pin marks, however, and some are extremely unpleasant to remove. At least one is smack in the middle of one of the deck gratings, which will make a very long and unhappy evening to remove. Modelers who have a few sailing ships under their belt may wish to replace a number of the parts with either brass or metal, such as the deck eyebolts for rigging. Likewise, the cord provided for rigging is very thick and needs finer thread for the running rigging of the ship. (Revell noted that in the rigging instructions, but I could swear that they provided it anyway in the original kit.)

Overall this is a big model when done up, it goes about 38" x 20" x 8" (965 x 500 x 200 mm) less its two plastic stands.   The use of the sails and pre-formed ratlines is a matter of taste (most ship modelers toss them upon opening the box) but for more lubberly ship builders like me they're fine, and my wife likes ships with the sails up.

One big problem with the kit that many people have pointed out is that it really isn't a true model of the Alabama. What Revell did was amortize the molds by cutting an accurate set of molds for the Kearsarge and them massaging them to look like the Alabama (hey, in 1961, who knew?). All of the pertinent features are here, but published plans show the actual vessel with more sheer (swoop at either end) and the kit, like the Kearsarge, is nearly flat. Also, the Alabama had a number of exotic features like rig that could be changed at whim to fool pursuers, as well as a retractable stack and propeller. The latter is featured on the kit (it also is a "working" feature) but not the former or the rig flexibility. (The real vessel was also recently found to have four flush toilets below decks, a first for the times.)   Also Revell's painting directions do not match contemporary sources which give quite a different picture of the famous cruiser, the actual ship being black overall with bare wood ("bright" and "drab" shades being noted) and sporting red, white and guilt trim.

But what the heck, it DOES look impressive on a mantel or a shelf where it can shine, and even at $65 in this day and age is a bargain!

Cookie Sewell
AMPS


June 11, 2000

Kit Review: ICM 1/35 Scale Figure Sets:

Kit No. 35161, "Conflict in Kosova 1999" Russian Spetsnaz VDV; 46 parts in light grey styrene; price between $5 and $8.

Kit No. 35221, "Soviet-Afghan War, 1979-1988" Mujahideen; 46 parts in light grey styrene; price between $5 and $8.

Advantages: nice, modern sets of subjects that have not been heavily covered.

Disadvantages; Muj are particularly wooden and static.

Rating: Highly Recommended.

Recommendation: to anyone doing modern Russians or Afghan war dioramas or vehicles.

For about eight years, DML ruled the roost with the best injection-molded figure sets around. They forced Tamiya to clean up its figures and start producing modern sets with correct proportions, as well as "set the bar" for many other manufacturers as well. The Russians and Ukrainians have taken note, and most of their more recent sets have been closing the gap with the Oriental manufacturers in quality.

These are two of the latest sets from ICM, who is on their way to becoming one of the dominant Eastern European manufacturers. They have purchased many smaller companies and are combining their lines with the original ICM offerings of 1/72 and 1/48 aircraft and 1/35 armor, and are now working on other areas such as figures and 1/350 ships. Their figure sets have been very good, and would seem to have used Tamiya and DML as their benchmark.

The first set is of four Russian soldiers in what could be termed "patrol" poses, which are all very well animated and reflect many of the photos seen from recent Russian combat deployments. While the box claims they are "Kosova" peacekeepers, they are more suited to use in either of the two Chechen campaigns (1994-1996 and 1999 to the present). The shoulder flashes given are for Kosova, but they are only shown on the box and without decals would be extremely difficult to copy in 1/35 scale. The troops come with an AKMS, an RPK machine gun with box magazine, an SVD rifle and what appears to be an obsolete Stechkin pistol with shoulder stock  and not the more common PM pistol. All weapons are petite in the DML manner. Facial details are good, and each man has a different headgear with one beret, one helmet, one watch cap, and one "do-rap" copy that has been quite popular in Chechnya. These figures would look great matched with any of the late model BTRs (70, 80 or BRDM) or a T-72 or T-62D tank (now reintroduced as it is easier to "fight" from in Chechen conditions).

The Mujahideen are of similar molding quality, but are very static that will really limit their usefulness. They look more like they came from the portrait artist's canvas than from real life, which is a shame. Each figure is quite different in dress, with three of the figures sporting turbans and one the little pork-pie hat preferred by Pushtuns. Weapons included are an M16 with M203 grenade launcher, a LAW or RPG-18 launcher, an AKM, the ubiquitous SVD rifle, and a Stinger missile launcher. The latter is apparently molded in the "carry" position with the cage portion of the sight folded up. It does not seem to be as well done as some of the others in DML or Tamiya kits, and should probably be replaced. The modeler could probably use the heads with other figures to create most modern resistance forces, to include Chechen mujahideen with Russian uniforms or some of the forces in the Middle East.

One minor comment. There really isn't such an animal as "Spetsnaz VDV". The Russians retained the Soviet force structure, and this includes VDV or Airborne troops, GRU SPETsNAZ, and other "power ministry" SPETsNAZ formations (i.e. MVD OMON troops). But to the average observer, the VDV and GRU troops look alike (blue berets and blue-and-white striped undershirts) and hence the term. In both Chechen wars, as well as much of the Afghan war, both the VDV and GRU SPETsNAZ used ground forces vehicles and equipment, such as the BTR-70 and BTR-80, so were again virtually indistinguishable to the casual eye.

Cookie Sewell
AMPS


April 16, 2000

Product Review: Archer Fine Transfers US Marking Sets:

AR35049 2nd and 3rd Armored Division Large Codes Sheet 1, price $9.95.

AR35050 2nd and 3rd Armored Division Large Codes Sheet 2, price $9.95.

AR35055W US Vehicle Registration Codes (White), price $6.95.

AR35065 US Bumper Codes WWII to Korea Non-Stencil type, price $6.95.

AR35066 US Bumper Codes WWII to Korea Stencil type, price $6.95.

Advantages: Best, sharpest images made, and fill a gap in US WWII armor markings.

Disadvantages: Require a bit more knowledge than wet transfers (decals) to apply.

Rating: Highly Recommended.

Recommendation: For all WWII and Korea US armor fans.

Those who did not attend the AMPS 2000 show in April 2000 missed a really fascinating and useful seminar by Woody Vondracek, who is the owner and chief employee of Archer Fine Transfers, into how these excellent markings are produced and how to use them at least three different ways.

As Woody noted in his short history of dry transfers, they were originally designed only for use by graphics artists on layouts and not designed to fit on three-dimensional objects. As a result, he uses a special layer of material that is elasticized to fit around bumps and grooves. Woody brought a short video that showed how each sheet is produced, and all of the steps involved. One sheet produced on its own takes up to 17 minutes of hands-on activity to produce to the point of letting it set for 2-3 days prior to packing.

Woody also demonstrated several good ways to use his transfers:

Dry are best for flat, easy to reach surfaces. (Note: all surfaces must be CLEAN, not necessarily smooth, for the transfers to work correctly. The transfers are then burnished onto the surface from the carrier sheet and once in place, rubbed again with the protector sheet on top of them (or any convenient piece of clean paper, such as bond paper) to get a tight adherence with the surface.

Wet/Dry are best for irregular surfaces such as Zimmermit or gratings. The transfer is attached to a sheet of decal paper (paper with adhesive but NO clear film). Once it is transferred, the markings are then soaked in water until they release from the decal paper. The marking is then floated into position and blotted with a makeup sponge. This presses it down into the grooves or notches and assures a good fit. The marking can then be further enhanced with decal setting solution such as MicroSol or Solvaset (Woody was using the Micro product).

Wet are best for long complex marking sets, such as specific vehicle numbers or serials, names, etc. The transfers are rubbed down onto a sheet of decal paper WITH clear film and then lightly coated with Micro Liquid Decal Film. The transfer is then cut from the sheet and used as a normal waterslide (decal) transfer.

Also recommended for use were: standard wooden cuticle pushers from beauty aids sections of drug stores, with a pointed tip and a flat tip; makeup sponges; a hard block for use in burnishing the transfers to other media such as decal paper; and a small paint brush for use with the wet/dry method to float the transfers into place.

For this show, Woody and his wife Jenny (who appears to be the packer, shipper, and management) had a vast selection of new markings for sale. The five sets listed above answer many of my personal wishes (and no, I had nothing to do with them!) as they cover many of my favorite subjects.

When the 2nd and 3rd Armored Divisions came ashore in Normandy, they were very difficult to tell apart at a distance as both divisions used nearly identical turret and side number codes. The codes were in yellow (recently confirmed by Steve Zaloga and others from newly discovered color photographs of the units at that time) and very prominent for the first six weeks of the campaign in France. Beginning with August 1944 many of the markings were painted out as they were found to draw the attention of German antitank gunners to the vehicles that was not a pleasant thing to do.

No one has yet encountered the regulation governing these codes, but there is a pattern that both divisions appear to have used to differentiate the regiments from one another. The 32nd (3rd) and 67th (2nd) Armored Regiments appear to have used the markings in a split fashion, with the stars used as dividers between the company code (letters) and the individual number. The 33rd (3rd) and 66th used them with a dash. The 36th and 41st Armored Infantry Regiments used them with dashes as well, or stacked with the letter above the number.

The companies all used a single letter (A to I) with some other letters used for specific vehicles and functions. The reconnaissance company used "R", the maintenance companies "M", and the battalion headquarters a digit (1, 2 or 3 followed by a dash and the vehicle's number). Regimental headquarters vehicles appear to be marked with a "P". Note: all this is based on observation, as the orders and regs are apparently no longer extant. One difference between 2AD and 3AD is that 2AD tanks used the flat plate type track links (i.e. T51 non-reversible) and 3AD used rubber chevron T48 track. This apparently was a division commander's order, as one order does exist for 2AD in which General Harmon orders all tracks in 2AD replaced with T54 type steel chevron track to provide the tanks with better traction during the fall of 1944.

The other sheets are excellently rendered markings for standard vehicles. New to the list are pre-formatted generic US registration numbers for tanks and other armored vehicles such as SP guns, halftracks, and tracked armored vehicles. Unless you need a precise match and extra digits are provided to replace some of those on the sheet they fill the bill pretty well. Both W and USA prefixes, as well as S suffixes, are also provided.

The bumper codes are also there, with generic prefixes set up make applying them easier. Researched by Kurt Laughlin, the markings are very thorough and will make life easier. Woody has also noted that after these sheets are done he will be switching to "number jungles" or mixed number rather than 0-9 runs to make setting them up on the model easier.

Overall, another great effort and one which definitely responds to need. Thanks to Woody and Jenny Vondracek for the review samples, and their time in presenting a very good seminar at AMPS 2000.

Cookie

Cookie Sewell
AMPS


April 16, 2000

Product Review: Fine Molds Fine Detail Accessories Set No. MG-24; WWII US Periscope Set 1 for M3, M4, M5, M18, M24, M26, and M36 Vehicles: 21 parts in clear styrene; price around $9.00.

Advantages: Crystal clear and very nicely detailed parts make the model.

Disadvantages: Installation and painting require a good deal of care to avoid damaging the parts; expensive.

Rating: Highly Recommended.

Recommendation: for all modelers of US built armored vehicles in Korea, WWII, and beyond.

Fine Molds of Japan has been successfully marketing what the British call "Bits" for some time, as well as a number of kits of Japanese armored vehicles. One of their newer releases are these items for US armored vehicles.

Many modelers get frustrated when they go to depict the periscopes and sights found on many US vehicles, as the parts provided in kits tend to be solid plastic if provided at all. Depending upon the modeler and skill level, the alternative is either paint or some sort of gloss coat, or drilling out the part and replacing it with plexiglass. However, detailing the latter is a pain, as styrene and plexiglass do not like adhering to each other, and using ACC glues can craze the plexiglass.

As a result, and following their German periscope sets, Fine Molds is now releasing US periscopes. The set consists of three identical sprues of five different parts that form a total of two different types of periscopes: No. 1 which is the standard US M6 semi-fixed viewer and hatch periscope; No. 2 which is the M10 gunner's periscope sight; No. 3 and No. 4 which are cemented together for form the M6 driver's hatch periscope in the M4 Sherman, and No 5 which is not listed in the directions. The kit provides for three M4 periscopes, six regular M6 periscopes, and six M6 periscopes as installed in the M4 series tank bow hatches.

Overall, this will be one of those really nice touches for a great Sherman model, and by using care in painting and installation should give some life to the periscopes.

Thanks to Bill Miley of Chesapeake Model Designs (who is carrying these items) for the review sample.

Cookie Sewell
AMPS


April 16, 2000

Kit Review: RHPS Models 1/35 Scale Accessories No. T48; T48 Rubber Chevron Tracks for M4 Series Tanks; 540 parts in grey styrene; Price $19.95 retail; No. T54; T54E1 Steel Chevron Tracks for M4 Series Tanks; 540 parts in grey styrene; Price $18.95 retail.

Advantages: First working track kit of these types of track in styrene.

Disadvantages: Some depressions in link faces require minor filling and sanding.

Rating: Highly Recommended.

Recommendation: For use on any M3 or M4 series vehicle using these types of track.

I was personally very happy last year when RHPS introduced their T49 and T51 track sets, and having put three sets of DML's T48 track together over the past 18 months was hoping that they would have their T48 set done for the AMPS 2000 show. They did, and it is worth the weight.

After their initial release tracks, RHPS changed the design of their tracks to use a similar system to that marketed by AFV Club with their T107 and T142 tracks. In this system the tracks simply snap together with two end connectors sliding over long end pins on each link, until a long enough length is created for a track run. Assembly is fast and simple, and the hardest part of assembly is cutting them off the sprues and cleanup.

While the T48 track is well-known and highly desired (they sold out of the items brought to AMPS 2000 very quickly), the T54E1 track is not as well known. However, photographs show it to be more common than the later T62 steel chevron track. The difference is that there are small gaps on either side of the T54E1 (actually spacers) and none on the T62. The T62 track is provided in the old Tamiya M4A3 kit.

Overall, this is a good deal and one which will please many modelers; this is particularly so now that a number of new kits with the popular M3/M4 suspension are coming out like the Academy M12 and the AFV Club M10.   RHPS Models accepts direct orders. Their address is PO Box 906, Massillon, Ohio, 44648 or telephone (330) 837-1031. Shipping is $4.50 per order for $10-50, $7.50 for $50 and up for UPS, or all orders can be sent via USPS postage paid (i.e. free shipping within the continental US).  Also available are T49 three block cleat and T51 non-reversible rubber block sets at $17.95 each.

Cookie Sewell
AMPS


April 16, 2000

Kit Review: Skybow 1.35 Military Series No. TP3506; General Patton's Command Car: U.S. 3/4 Ton WC57 Command and Reconnaissance; 213 parts (202 in olive drab styrene, 6 vinyl keepers; 4 clear styrene; 1 nylon string); Price $32.95.

Advantages: Completely new model literally blows away Peerless Max kit; promise of new "Beep" kits to come should be of excellent quality.

Disadvantages: May prove harder to find in some cases than other brands.

Rating: Highly Recommended.

Recommendation: To All US Vehicle Modelers.

F I R S T    L O O K

It's nice to see older "Dog Pound" material kits replaced by newer, state-of-the-art kits, especially when their prices aren't too far out of line with the norm. Such is the case here with Skybow's gorgeous new kit of "Patton's Command Car".

The kit actually provides more than enough parts, including what are obviously parts for the rest of the Dodge WC-5X series vehicles. The kit provides parts for either Patton's WC-57 model command car with winch or a WC-56 without winch from the 82nd Airborne Division or 83rd Infantry Division. Patton's 3rd Army command flags and pennants, as well as very delicate styrene panels for mounting them, are included as well.

This model has absolutely nothing in common with the 25-year old Peerless Max (Italeri, Testors, Bilek) kit except for its subject. It comes with an amazingly detailed Dodge T214 engine of 18 parts by itself. Even the windshield takes seven parts to complete. While petite, none of the parts used in any assembly are "fussy" parts like those used by Heller, e.g. why use two parts to an assembly when seven are just fine? The kit also includes one of Skybow's excellent M2HB .50 caliber machine guns and other small details.

The kit comes with a clearly illustrated nine-page direction book, but while it is well illustrated it needs a better speller! Case in point is when the directions call for winding the "spring" around the winch drum prior to installation.

All in all this is a great little model, and while the price is higher than would seem fair for the size of the model, its quality is up with the best, rivaling that of most of the latest Tamiya kits such as the GMC and Jeep. The boxtop would indicate that perhaps their next release will be the WC-51/52 Dodge 3/4 Weapons Carrier, which also will be very welcome by fans of American vehicles.

Cookie Sewell
AMPS


April 5, 2000

Kit Review: ROCO 1/87 Scale Minitanks No. 705; Pzkw. IV Ausf. H; 31 parts in tan styrene; price $6-8.

Advantages: Complete makeover for a 40+ year old model, nice proportions, NO WHEELS!

Disadvantages: Missing some details, such as AA MG, some minor simplification, and an odd air cleaner installation.

Rating: Highly Recommended.

Recommendation: for all war gamers and "Small Scale" armor fans.

Many of us cut our armor modeling teeth on Monogram, Aurora, and Revell kits during the 1950s and early 1960s, but when we looked around for more than dozen vehicle kits (including "bad guys") the only source of supply was ROCO of Austria with its "HO" scale line of Minitanks. We learned the wrong names and designations for vehicles, including prototypes that never went into service, but they had a large selection and they were CHEAP. One dollar bought two to four tanks, and that was all that mattered.

One of those first models was the German Pzkw. IV tank, which came in three models: F1, F2, and H. Few of us read any references, so it was only much later in life that it was noted that these were specific models of the tank and that this tank is not the Tiger, "King Tiger", or Panther that was the mainstay of German armored formations in WWII. The models were pretty sketchy at best, being 1/100 scale and not HO, and the details were subordinated to fast assembly and wheels to move on when rolled on the carpet. All of them had easily broken and lost hatches, oversized and incorrect machine guns, and big holes where they fastened together and the crummy wheels on the bottom.

Now, 40 years later, these models have been dropped from the line and a brand new model of the Pzkw. IV series has been released which IS in 1/87 scale and IS a clearly visible Model H version of the tank. While it does retain ROCO's standard one-piece track runs, the hull consists of not two parts, but five main ones: bow, belly, rear, fender and glacis, and upper hull. The arrangement suggests they are going to do the entire line of Panzer IV tanks as these parts must be replaced for earlier models and some of the other variants. It also has a late-model one-piece hatch and the "schuertzen" armor of the H seen in most photographs. This consists of a new one-piece section for the turret (with built-in bustle bin) and the two side skirts, that now come with three of the side braces (the most visible ones, as the others are hard to see in this scale with the skirts in place.) Also included are the muffler, antenna mount, headlight, bow machine gun, spare tracks, jack, four spare road wheels, and a curious air cleaner mounted on the right fender. I don't have any new references that would explain it, but it looks to be a desert fitting which would seem odd on most H models that fought in Russia or the western front.

The only comments I have heard about this is some question as to the accuracy of the gun. It appears pretty close without measuring it (it is FAR better than the "blob on a pin" barrel from the earlier model kits) but is smaller than the one that comes with the 30+-year-old StuG III from ROCO. It also does not have the baffles in the muzzle brake cleaned out, and this will be tedious for anyone wanting a more accurate model. IT also appears the AA MG will be an after market purchase as well.

Overall, this is a major quality upgrade to an old standard, and one for which ROCO should be complimented, even if at least 30 years overdue. Also coming in the near future are Panther models from ROCO's symbiotic competitor, Trident. For small-scale German armor fans and war gamers, things are surely looking up.

Thanks to Art Wollam for the loan of the review sample.

Cookie Sewell
AMPS


April 2, 2000

Kit Review: Arsenal 1/35 Scale Military Miniature Series No. 001, Soviet Armored Reconnaissance Vehicle BRDM-1; 149 parts (145 in grey styrene and 4 in black vinyl); price between $22-35, dependent upon source.

Advantages: First kit of this vehicle in styrene; quality approaching DML in some areas; ejection pin marks molded proud for easy removal.

Disadvantages: Missing a lot of interior details, such as the "sidesaddle" seats in the rear of the crew compartment; also missing its SGM machine gun and mounting.

Rating: Highly Recommended.

Recommendation: To armored car and Soviet armor fans, particularly "Cold Warriors".

F I R S T    L O O K

Okay, so this kit has been around a bit and it's only now and with the kindness of Bob Lessels of Eastern Front Hobbies I could get a copy to review. But unlike some other recent kits, this one is a little jewel and has a lot of promise for the company and the future.

After the close of WWII, the Soviets did a large number of studies of eastern and western Europe, and determined that they would come to a sizeable water crossing every ten kilometers on a drive to the Rhein River. As a result, they went back to their pre-war concept of light armored vehicles for reconnaissance. The first two vehicles, the PT-76 and the BTR-40, were planned to fit in with this concept. However, while the PT-76 was amphibious, the BTR-40 emerged as non-amphibious and could only serve as an updated version of the WWII Lend Lease M3A1 White Scout Car. As a result, as the PT-76 was seen as too big for regimental reconnaissance, a new armored amphibian had to be created.

The new vehicle, better known as the Bronyevaya Razvedivatel'no-Dozornaya Mashina or Armored Patrol and Reconnaissance Vehicle, was placed in service in 1957. It carried a crew of two and three to five dismount scouts (three was the unit structure design norm, but seats were provided for five in a pinch). The chassis was lifted from the GAZ-63 light truck, and it used the proven water jet technology of the PT-76 light tank for water propulsion. Armament consisted of a single 7.62mm SGM machine gun mounted on a pedestal between the driver-mechanic (left side) and commander (right side) at the junction of the upper glacis/windshield and roof.

The vehicle was successful in this role, and also as that of a command vehicle in other formations; but it was also considered cramped and under armed for its mission. Six years later, a new model, the BRDM-2, was developed and placed in service. This had a higher and more capacious hull, better swimming capabilities, and most importantly, a turret with coaxial 14.5mm and 7.62mm machine guns. It also had IR lights for better night reconnaissance and combat capabilities.

There were three other versions of the BRDM-1 placed in service: the 2P27, 2P32, and 9P110, which were launcher platforms for the AT-1, AT-2 and AT-3 ATGM missiles respectively. There were two minor versions produced as well, the BRDM-U command model, and the BRDM-RKh chemical and radiological reconnaissance model.

Arsenal's kit is nicely done, and the fact that the entire belly is provided as a single part is very helpful to the modeler. The body consists of six parts: chassis pan, sides, front, rear and back panel. All are cleanly molded, and the front section even comes with louvers molded in the open position. The front and rear sections are designed to fit together at a weld joint, which makes assembly and cleanup a bit easier.

The BRDM series trademark "Belly" wheels are included, along with their chain drives, and look to be at least as good as the DML ones with their BRDM-2 series. Many of the holes for parts are shared with what appears to be at least the 9P110 ATGM version, so be prepared to drill out the openings you need. The directions for this kit are incredibly busy and hard to understand, and some of those items seem to have slipped by.

The interior is very basic, as it includes the five normal seats, an instrument panel, steering wheel, and some control levers. It is missing much of the interior details and stowage, which is a shame as it has four big hatches that can be opened up to show this off. It is also missing any glazing for the rear of the front windows, but considering the quality of some of the Russian kits (this kit is Ukrainian, but the standards are similar among all of the Eastern European manufacturers) it is probably better to provide that yourself from clear styrene.

The only unfortunate omission in the kit is the SGM machine gun, which is much harder to replace from the spares box. Most Soviet kits either come with DT machine guns or postwar heavies like the NST and KShM.. Some modelers have recommended replacing this with a PKT from the DML Modern Machine Guns Set, but most of the BRDM-1s were pretty much out of service and gone when the PKT entered service itself. You also need to scratchbuild the pylon and mount for the gun.

Overall, however, this is a very nice little kit and will work well with some Cold War scenes, of which the Czech invasion is provided with the kit as a decal and paint option. Markings are furnished for both the BRDM-1 and 9P110 on one sheet, but the options include Guards units, VMF Naval Infantry, Polish, and what appear to be either Egyptian or Syrian markings.

Cookie Sewell
AMPS


April 2, 2000

Kit Review: Maquette 1/35 Red Army Collection Kit No. MQ-3562; FAI-M Russian Armoured Car; 107 parts (45 in black styrene, 40 in green styrene, 16 in tan styrene, and 6 in grey styrene); price estimated at $15-22.

Advantages: Provides an FAI armored car body with a BA-20 kit.

Disadvantages: Cannot make an FAI-M out of this kit as is.

Rating: Recommended with Reservations.

Recommendation: for diehard Soviet or armored car fans who don't mind doing some Scratchbuilding.

F I R S T    L O O K

I admit to getting lazy in my old age. I don't mind doing the legwork to produce a decent review of a model, but when someone has done all of the "Donkey Work" first, I will pay attention to what the other reviewer noted, particularly when I can see that he is right.

Case in point: there is a very thorough review of this kit by N. Polikarpov on page 5 of the new issue of "M-Khobbi" magazine which is not kind to the kit at all. Mr. Polikapov notes that Maquette tried to take a page from DML in using one kit of a known item "the START BA-20 kit" and provide it with the body of an FAI armored car to create an FAI-M. This is what the Soviets did in 1938, or at least so it says on paper. Actually, the FAI armored car body was designed and built by the Izhorsk factory to go on a GAZ-A (1929 Ford Model A copy) chassis in 1932. It had a very stylish body that had angled sides to increase the armor thickness and give more "graze" angles to ricochets and shell fragments. When they went to do just that in 1938 - mount the FAI body on a new GAZ-M1 (a less accurate copy of a 1936 Ford) they had to do a lot of redesign work to get the FAI body to fit on the new chassis. The lower body panels were changed, and a new roof design was required to get the new sides connected to each other. This apparently didn't dawn on Maquette, and as a result, the kit is a non-existent vehicle.

What you get in the box are the two START BA-20 sprues (the green and black ones) and two news sprues, apparently made from leftover styrene pellets from other kits. The grey parts in this kit cover the FAI body, and the tan ones the roof and turret bits.

Mr. Polikarpov does explain where most of the errors in the kit are for the determined modeler who wants to turn this into a replica of an FAI-M, and does give indication that there are good plans of an FAI-M in issue 6-99 of M-Khobbi magazine. (I did not have them to check, but after finding a shot of a honest-to-goodness FAI-M in Janusz Magnewski's book "Red Blitzkrieg" the differences are quite obvious.)

For any of you who have purchased this kit and gotten frustrated in the process of trying to get the parts to line up, you now know why they don't. My suggestion is to keep this kit and either get the magazine and make the new body parts necessary to turn it into an FAI-M, or build it as a BA-20 and save the body parts until you can find either a 1/35 scale Ford Model A chassis or a GAZ-A kit. (These may be a long time in coming.)

Thanks to Bob Lessels of Eastern Front Hobbies for the review sample.

Cookie Sewell
AMPS


February 23, 2000

Kit Review: Trumpeter 1/35 Scale Armored Vehicles Series Kit No. 319; Type 98 Chinese Streamline Main Battle Tank; 243 parts (220 in dark OD styrene, 18 clear vinyl, 2 black vinyl, 1 nylon screen, 1 steel axle, 1 screw); price around $35 ($26 through APC Hobbies).

Advantages: First kit of this tank anywhere; some nice touches and details.

Disadvantages: Molding similar to early Academy copies of Tamiya kits; some rough spots; parts optimized for motorization.

Rating: Recommended.

Recommendation: For all modern armor and PLA fans.

F I R S T L O O K.

While most modelers are now familiar with "Shanghai Dragon", the mainland branch of Dragon Models Limited (DML) from Hong Kong, few other Chinese manufacturers have yet surfaced until now. Trumpeter began releasing models last spring (1999) and no less a person than George Balin brought one of their Type 85 kits down to the AMPS 99 show. The moldings were in a neat tan plastic, and the kit had promise.

Trumpeter has an announced line of 14 armor kits, along with 1/72. 1/48, and 1/32 aircraft kits. This is the "flagship" kit, as it covers the very latest Chinese Peoples' Liberation Army main battle tank that was first shown last fall at the 50th Anniversary of the Revolution Parade in Beijing. These tanks were paraded in the third group that (the Chinese military being efficient and not wanting any screw ups in front of Western guests) were coded with English letters as "C" group. (The kit comes with those markings, as well as generic numbers for line units).

There is not word one in the directions or on the box about this tank, as it is so new that the manufacturer seems to have assumed it was still classified by the PLA. The tank is a hybrid Chinese tank that evolved from the earlier Type 85-II and Type 85-IIM tanks, which were the first of a new series of designs that finally broke the lineal descent from the Soviet T-54 tank via the Type 59 and Type 69 series. It has a composite armor hull and turret which appear to be jointly influenced by the T-72 and the M-1 Abrams.

The tank mounts a 120mm separate-loading ammunition gun with an autoloader, and has a crew of three. A lightened version of the Soviet "Dushka" provides air defense protection, as well as a coaxial 7.62mm machine gun. The tank has a modern fire control system with a combination wind sensor and laser detector on a mast at the rear of the turret (kit parts C41 and C44). One surprise when the tank was paraded was that it also came with a second-generation slewing laser blinder device to use against ATGM and tank sights and tracking devices (parts C6, C7, C9, C45, and C46).

The Type 98 (so designated as it was the year of introduction, 1998) comes with "boom shields" on the rear of the turret and ten smoke grenade launchers. It has a high horsepower diesel engine and weighs in the 42-46 metric ton class.

Trumpeter, obviously having some help from the PLA but not a great deal to go with on this model, has done a nice job of capturing the unique items on the tank which make it different from Western and Russian designs. The kit is unfortunately designed for motorization and is a throwback to the "bad old days" with huge slots and screw holes in the belly. There is a screw hole in the bow to hold the motorized version together, and a very unrealistic molded on scraper under the leading edge of the bow.

The kit has some nice touches, such as the operating wires for the Type 98's smoke projectors molded in place. But for every "attaboy" there is an "oh nuts". The tracks are equivalent to early "second generation" Tamiya ones in that they have interior details, but very weak definition on items like the end connectors (this tank uses a Diehl-type twin-pin "live" track similar to the Leopard 1 and 2.) The AA machine gun could better be replaced by some of the better DML or Italeri plastic DShK guns, as it has ejection pin marks where they are inconvenient to remove.

The kit comes with a T-72 style suspension (which is correct) but one it appears to share with the Type 85-II kits also produced by Trumpeter. Note that this means a bevy of extra smoke grenade launchers for those tanks.

Details are plainly molded, but most appear serviceable. Some small details appear crude, but most are similar enough to some of the DML parts from their later models that replacing them should not be too difficult. Two sets of drivers are included; one is apparently the Type 85-II   set and the other appears to be the Type 98 set. (The larger of the two is the Type 98 model from the "D" sprue.)

A painting chart is included, and it appears to be keyed to Tamiya acrylics. For those not using the colors, my best guess is that German Panzer Yellow, German Panzer Green, and FS34079 should match pretty well.

Overall, for a first rush of kits, the Trumpeter models are not too bad, and a nice model can be built from the kit with a bit of work. Thanks to Leo and Andre at APC Hobbies for the rush order!

Cookie Sewell
AMPS


February 23, 2000

Kit Review: Trumpeter 1/35 Scale Armored Vehicles Series Kit No. 318; Chinese Type 80 Main Battle Tank; 267 parts (244 in dark OD styrene, 2 black vinyl, 1 nylon screen, 1 nylon string, 1 steel axle, 3 clear styrene, and 15 screws) price around $35 ($26 via APC Hobbies).

Advantages: First kit of this tank anywhere.

Disadvantages: Designed for motorization; screw assembly a major hassle to fill and clean up; turret appears to share same problems as many other T-54 based models.

Rating: Recommended with reservations.

Recommendation: For T-54 family and PLA fans.

F I R S T    L O O K

The Chinese took the basic A.A. Morozov T-54 design and ran it through a vast number of permutations and stretches. The last versions began to change in form and shape, and the assessment has been that the Type 85-I tank was the swan song of the design in Chinese hands. The basic tank went through the Type 59 series (five models of Type 59, 59A, 59B, 59C, and 59D), the Type 69 series (Type 69-I, 69-II in three models, and 69-III), the Type 79, and the Type 80. In the Type 80, the modifications up to the Type 79 (new fire control system, new engine, new 105mm L7 based gun) were combined with a suspension reminiscent of the Egyptian "Ramses" which combined a T-54/55 tank with an M60 suspension. The tank weighed in at 38 metric tons, and could be fitted with a variety of options as well as the rest of the Type 59 family (i.e. any or all of eight "packages" including "Boom shield" bar armor, searchlights, laser range finders, etc.) The Type 80 also had a composite armor glacis and a dual use laser rangefinder/gunner's primary sight.

Trumpeter's model appears to share a great deal of its parts with other kits. The tracks, running gear, and belly pan are from the Type 85-II kits (they say so on the parts) and the turret appears to be from the Type 69/79 series of kits. Only the upper hull and details appear to be unique to this tank, but may be shared with the Type 85-II (I can't tell.) The Type 80 used a new engine, and instead of the "pizza oven" exhaust on the left of the traditional T-54 based hull, it has two direct exit stacks on the right.

The turret is better than some of the T-54/55 efforts. It does have the correct offset to the right of the gun to clear the gunner's position and has some nice weld detail. Many other details are plain but function (hey, unlike ESCI they at least have three identical sized fuel tanks!) and open frame fender braces. But the lower hull is a throwback to the early 1960s with molded on road wheel arms, and the wheels install with screws to permit free rotation. Detail on the wheels themselves is not too bad, but you will have to come up with some sort of cap to seal the resulting holes in the center of the road wheels as Trumpeter didn't bother to do it for you. With the skirts in place, the suspension may not be that bad. The lower hull is awful, though, as it even has a big ON-OFF molded by the switch position for the motorized version! Out come the files, scrap and putty.

Overall, the Type 80 is not as bad as some efforts, and in areas is better than the ESCI T-55 kit. But this is not a first-rank kit, and from what it shows, the Type 59 and Type 69 series kits are not bull's-eyes either. If you want a Type 80, I can recommend the kit if you are aware of its needs. Like the Type 98 tank, it also includes "parade decals" from the October 1999 Beijing Parade (these were the first tanks and in the "A" group.)

Cookie Sewell
AMPS


February 9, 2000

Kit Review: Fruilmodel 1/35 Scale Cast White Metal Track Sets.

Kit No. ATL-54, JS-1/JS-2/JS-3/JSU-122/JSU-152 Light Type Tracks; 186 parts in white metal plus a roll of light steel wire; price $30.00.

Kit No. ATL-55, T-60/T-70 Track; 212 parts in white metal plus a roll of light steel wire; price $26.95.

Advantages: New lower prices; clean, neat tracks; gives heft to lightweight models (T-60/T-70 only).

Disadvantages: Some modelers do not like "kink push clip" assembly method; Soviet light tank tracks very small and fiddly.

Rating: Highly Recommended.

Recommendation: for anyone building specific Soviet vehicles (see text below).

One of the major complaints many modelers have had about Fruilmodel white metal tracks, which are the best of any white metal track sets going right now, is that they were far more expensive than competing plastic or resin sets. Fruilmodel has now found a way around this, and the prices are now some $10 a set less. The reason for this is right on the top of the bag: their production facility is now in Urhida, Hungary. The molds are developed in Italy and then sent to Hungary for production; Fruili cuts costs, you save money, and the Hungarians have another model product on the market. Good deal all around. This is the same for the older sets: $39.95 sets will retail for $30, and $36.95 sets for $26.95.

The JS set follows on the heels of the very nice resin set from Anvil Models of Australia that I reviewed in October 1999. As I noted in that review, these tracks were made at Factory No. 185, better known as the Chelyabinsk Kirov Tank Factory. These were referred to as "three piece cast track links" which were listed on early IS series tanks. ChTZ cast one link with the guide horn in the center, and two half-links that joined in the middle without a horn. The reason for this is unknown, but one reason for having every other tooth missing was a problem noted with the KV series (which used a similar design of track, albeit with only one design) where mud and debris would build up between the wheels and horns and jam the track, or worse, cause them to be thrown.

Partway through the production run of the IS-2 tank, it was realized that this was not a big problem, and the cost was too high for the Peoples' Commission on Tank Production that ordered them to economize. A new single design with a guide horn was used; it was found to be simpler and faster for those who still believed the extra guide horns were a problem to simply cut the tooth flush with a torch. The tracks were designed to be assembled with odd-even pairs, i.e. one toothed link to every two half-links. However, photos exist of the tanks with a string of toothed links together, so there was not a fit problem. This was probably due to mines or other damage-necessitating repair.

These tracks would be found on IS-2 tanks of the earlier production runs and the very early ISU-122 and ISU-152 vehicles, but not the late models or the IS-3. If you don't like the fussiness of snapping three piece resin tracks together, and have no problems with the "kink the wire, push it in, clip it off" method of assembling recent Fruili track sets, this is a nice set to use.

The other set covers essentially most of the mid to late war Soviet light tanks to include the T-30 and T-40,   but is optimized for the Techmod T-60 and T-70/T-70M kits. Both of these models are very light and very petite, and literally can "blow away" if not fixed to a base. The use of white metal track provides some heft to the models, but even so, these are very petite links and very light themselves. They are also suitable for use on the SU-76M kit from Alan/DML, which has very nasty tracks to deal with, but I don't think there are enough links in the packet to fit the SP chassis. The T-40 and T-60 each took 87 links per side, and the T-70 had to use more for the extra road wheel, so I don't think it has the "stretch" to fit that kit.

Overall, these are nice track sets, and if you like metal, they are the ones to pick.

Thanks to Bill Miley of Chesapeake Model Designs for the review samples.

Cookie Sewell
AMPS


February 9, 2000

Kit Review:   Royal Models 1/35 Scale Diorama Accessories: No. 202, U.S. Army Equipment WWII; 156 parts (37 in tan resin and 119 in etched brass); Price $26.95.

No. 212, U.S. Tank Equipment; 23 parts in tan resin; price $17.95.

Advantages: "One stop" shopping for detail accessories and "kit" for vehicles or dioramas.

Disadvantages: Etched brass straps may be a bit difficult for some people to get a good appearance.

Rating: Highly Recommended.

Recommendation: for all WWII or Korean War US Modelers or anyone who wants US kit in a diorama.

Royal Models is a pretty decent Italian manufacturer of detail accessories and figures, and most modelers who have been to one of the AMPS National Conventions have seen their items for sale with several of the vendors. They have primarily done German items until now, but these two accessory sets are very nice and of interest to armor modelers who deal with US subjects.

Kit 202 provides a wealth of basic US Army infantry gear from the WWII era, which means it also works for Korea. This includes one layout of dropped gear (helmet and web gear) as well as map cases, packs, helmets, canteens and belts. The main difference in this kit from several others is that all of the strapping is included, but as part of an etched brass fret. The brass is incredibly well detailed, with the wales on the web belt and grommets standing out as spectacular, but getting them to drape realistically will cause some modelers problems. Start by annealing the metal over a flame before use to take some of the stiffness out of the brass, and the rest will be much easier. This also will need some sort of anvil or tool such as the Small Shop's "Hold and Fold" to get clean breaks in the parts, as 1/35 chinstrap buckles are a bit puny for most of us hamhanded types to get off on our own!

Kit 212 was not well served in translation from Italian, as it is not quite what it claims to be, but rather a dress-up set for US military vehicles with several packs, a roll of camouflage netting, regular steel pots and tankers' helmets, and "stuff" which would be found on the rear of turrets or engine decks. All is crisply molded, but the big pieces have some hefty casting feet that will take care in removal. This has more applicability than some other offerings from other manufacturers, as it is generic enough to use on any vehicle rather than one specific kit from one specific manufacturer.

Overall, these are nice sets and give the average modeler the chance to add some nice bits to their models with a minimum of fuss and without using the same tired plastic accessories that come with some kits.

Royal Models products are available directly from Chesapeake Model Designs, PO Box 393, Monkton, MD 21111. Thanks to Bill Miley of CMD for the review samples.

Cookie Sewell
AMPS


January 14, 2000

Kit Review: AFV Club 1/35 Scale Kit No. AF 35024; M-10 Tank Destroyer; 333 parts (322 in olive drab styrene, 8 vinyl, 1 nylon string, 1 aluminum barrel and 1 steel spring); retail prices estimated at $32-36

Advantages: Finally, a first-rate modern kit of this vehicle in styrene!

Disadvantages: "Not German", some minor glitches and errors, somewhat "fussy" assembly of AFV Club kits not some modelers' cup of tea

Rating: Highly Recommended

Recommendation: For all US and Tank Destroyer fans

F I R S T   L O O K

The mantra of the theme of "Field of Dreams" is "build it, and he will come." The scratch builders' mantra always seems to be "build it, and someone will make a kit of it." I seriously hoped for this back in 1994 when I did up a pair of WWII US tank destroyers, an M10 3" Gun Motor Carriage (GMC) and an M36 90mm GMC. When Tamiya announced an M10, I felt "Great! Here comes a new kit to match their German reworkings!" But as the game show host always says, "BZZT! Wrong!" They simply re-released their obsolete and awful kits from the early days.

There was some wariness among those of us who fancy US armor when AFV Club announced this kit in late 1998 as in the works. Some speculated that it would be a re-worked Academy M10 kit with some ROC fittings added. The wait is now over, and to my personal delight, the kit is a masterpiece of the mold maker's art and TOTALLY new from the ground up!

Before I start foaming at the mouth over how good this kit really is, first the "bad news". The kit has a number of minor sink holes in some parts, but most are easily remedied with putty. There are a number of ejection pin marks on the parts, but all are of the "proud" variety and in places where they are fairly easy to remove and correct. Considering the complexity of the molding used in this kit, one has to accept the fact that you don't get a one piece lower hull and upper hull without some fancy multipart molds which need

pins to ensure a clean "pull" of the parts. The only minor error I noted is, and this based on the research I did on my conversion in ‘94 and not all-consuming, is that the model comes with the correct "lace" type drivers, solid cast road wheels, but the wrong solid-cast idler rather than the "spoke" idler which appears to have been most common on the prototypes. Also, while the kit provides new road wheels of what appears to be the correct width (what a concept!) they are hollow-backed, which some modelers find objectionable.

Now for the good news. This kit is absolutely AMAZING with the amount of detail it provides, and the quality of the molding. It matched up very well with the old Ordnance Museum plans for the M10A1 (GAA powered late model; this is the twin GMC diesel version, the M10). The hull consists of exactly four parts: lower hull with complete fender liners and sponsons intact, a separate rear panel, a separate transmission cover, and a one-piece upper hull with separate rear panel, both of which have the lower angled panels and fenders in place. A separate engine deck grille is included to permit access later for those who wish to put an engine in this model (Note: The Tank Workshop makes an M4A2 power pack which is apropos for this model).

The model comes with a relatively complete interior forward of the firewall, but due to the inability to see inside, has left out the drivers' controls, but includes the transmission itself. The drivers' hatches each consist of six parts, and moreover, are operating when installed.

The suspension is brand new, and not a copy of previous efforts by Tamiya or Italeri. Each bogie, which is the intermediate "flat-topped" idler variety, consists of eleven styrene parts and a vinyl spring assembly, which the directions indicate make it operate correctly. This feature may not be well received, but the springs appear no worse than on any other Sherman kit on the market today. The part diagram casting numbers, D47526, can be read on each bogie and are nicely done.

Most popular with many modelers will be the tracks. The kit comes with T49 "three bar steel cleat" style tracks, but they are vinyl components and very, very nicely done. There are zero injection pin marks on them, and only a few "teats" left over from the molding process. The connectors are in the right place, and one can even see daylight between the links. AFV Club claims they are cementable tracks, but that is something that I have not tried yet. The quality of this set raises the bar once again on the other companies.

The outside of the upper hull includes all of the appliqué armor "bosses" for mounting as separate parts, and I note that there are tiny circles for locating in the upper hull and turret sides. This is objectionable to some, but makes placement sure and easy (I had to do it with a template on the conversions, which is not recommended!) You even have a choice - bosses with the "keeper" bolts in place, or bolts removed. Grouser racks are included, and a total of 26 individual grousers are included with the kit.

The turret is the mid-production one with the V-shaped back and wedge-shaped counterweights. Details are similar to the one in the M18 kit, included the "recoiling" gun with spring. However, due to the negative comments on the M18's pudgy brass barrel, this model includes a machined aluminum one like the M59 155mm and M102 105mm artillery kits. The shape is less bulged than the M18's gun, but the 3" gun was more bulged out than the similar M1 76m gun series and this looks fairly accurate.

The kit comes with the correct cardboard tubes for the below-the-turret ring ammunition, but does not include any 3"/76mm rounds for the turret ready rack. AFV Club suggests the model use the brass set (AF 35018) which they developed for their M18 kit. Likewise, for modelers who do not want the T49 track, they recommend their single link T51 flat rubber pad set (AF 35026).

Markings and painting instructions are included for six different vehicles: the well-known "Pistol-Packin' Mama" from the Tank Destroyer School at Camp Hood, TX, 1943, with the big "Crunchin' Kitty" painted on the back of the turret; 634th TD Battalion, Germany, 1944; ROC Army, Jinmen Island 1958; French 2nd Armored Division, France 1944; another French 2nd Armored Division vehicle, 1945; and an unidentified French vehicle from 1945. Decals are passable, but my example was missing the Cross of Lorraine device on the 2nd DB insignia. I recommend picking up one of Steve Zaloga's books on US Tank Destroyers (the Tanks Illustrated No. 19 one is out of print, but the one from Concord, no. 7005, is still available.)

Overall, this is a good model and really one that has been needed for a long, long time. Box art, mostly cartoons, would tend to indicate that we can expect to see an Achilles and an M36, as well as perhaps the M35 gun tractor, in the future on this chassis.

Thanks once again to the indomitable Shirley Lin of Hobbyfan for the review samples. This time, you made my day!

Cookie Sewell
AMPS


January 14, 2000

Kit Review: AFV Club 1/35 Scale M3 and M4 Series Tank Accessories

Kit No. AF35026; M4 Sherman Vertical Volute Spring Suspension Unit

(Horizontal Return Roller); 88 parts (82 in olive styrene and six in black vinyl); price estimated at $13-15

Kit No. AF35027; M4 VVSS Sherman T49 Track 79/Track x 2 (two parts in black vinyl); price not given, but estimated at $5-8.

Kit No.  AF35029; M4 Workable T51 Track; 624 parts in black styrene; price estimated at $13-15.

Advantages: Outstanding components to replace kit parts in M3 and M4 series tank model kits; reasonable prices and good quality an advantage; inclusion of extenders in the T51 kit a great idea

Disadvantages: Some minor glitches in the suspension set; ejection pin marks may annoy some; popular choice items may be scarce to find in some areas.

Rating: Highly Recommended.

Recommendation: For all fans of the US medium tank chassis and its VVSS variants.

Okay, fellow "Shermaholics", someone is finally answering your prayers! AFV Club has now waded into the fray with the first three of what hopes to be a large series of specialty market items for the M3 and M4 series tanks. All of the items are up to AFV Club's standards, and are far better than any of the other major commercial (i.e. major manufacturers' injection molded) items on the market.

Most popular with many modelers will be the single-section vinyl tracks. These are the T49 three-bar cleat steel tracks, which are provided stock with the M10 3" GMC kit (No. AF35024). There are zero injection pin marks on them, and only a few "teats" left over from the molding process. The connectors are in the right place, and one can even see daylight between the links. AFV Club claims they are cementable tracks, but that is something that I have not tried yet. The quality of this set raises the bar once again on the other companies. (Incidentally, Tamiya could have been making big bucks for at least the past ten years if they had done this with their vinyl tracks, as many modelers have that as their one major complaint against DML kits and single-link injected tracks.)

For those with a more adventurous spirit, AFV Club has also now provided a single-link set of Sherman series tank tracks in its T51 set. These are the "reversible" flat rubber pad tracks, which were probably the most common, and used from the M2 through the end of M4 series production. While there are injection pin marks on the face of each link, they are raised or "proud" and easily trimmed or sanded off.

These are similar to the great sets they have done for the M48/M60 series and M-1 series tanks, and assemble in a similar manner. While no directions are included, the spacing and placement on the trees makes this a snap. First, trim off all of the links and clean them up. Next, cut the bars with the connectors off the sprue frame INTACT and leave the connectors in place. Insert the links into the connectors so that one link has one pin in each adjacent connector. Then, once a section is done, line up and press the other section in place. This takes some dexterity, but if done correctly, you can quickly knock together 28-link sections of track. Note that a normal Sherman hull needs 79, and an M4A4 hull 84 or three complete sprues' worth.

Also included as an option are 120 extended end connectors. These cement on to the ends of the connectors once they are in place, so be careful. I would recommend waiting until the tracks are in place or sorted out before cementing them in to avoid "freezing" the flexibility of the tracks.

Lastly is the mid-production VVSS Sherman suspension with the "flat-top" return roller mounting. The suspension is brand new, and not a copy of previous efforts by Tamiya or Italeri. The kit includes new "lace" type early drivers with a unique way of mounting and operating, as well as a cast idler. Each bogie consists of eleven styrene parts and a vinyl spring assembly. This feature may not be well received, but the springs appear no worse than on any other Sherman kit on the market today. The part diagram casting numbers, D47526, can be read on each bogie and are nicely done. The provision of this set as a separate kit permits modelers with the Tamiya, Italeri, or DML kits to replace or modify the suspension with a nicer, cleaner, and more accurate suspension for the mid-term production VVSS equipped tanks.

Overall, a great idea for Sherman fans. Now, if Pete Harlem can just get Part II of his Sherman series of books out...

Thanks to Shirley Lin of Hobbyfan for the review samples.

Cookie Sewell
AMPS